Aren’t Nationalism and Socialism contradictory? I mean in one the people serve the State while in the other the State serves the people. Not as dumb as Anarcho Capitalism, but still silly.
Yes. Fools will tell you the Nazis were socialists, people of a normal intelligence will tell you that calling yourself a duck does not make you a duck.
The issue is that both terms are valid and well defined in political science, but “socialism” and “national socialism” are not significantly related and it is disingenuous to even call national socialism a type of socialism.
Good point!
“The full name of the Nazi Party was Nationalsozialistische Deutsche Arbeiterpartei (German for ‘National Socialist German Workers’ Party’)”
Gee, I wonder how anyone could possibly come to that conclusion?
I bet you’re confused by buffalo wings
HAHAHAHA
Hence “calling yourself a duck does not make you a duck”
Yeah it’s like thinking the “Democratic peoples Republic of Korea” is somehow democratic.
I understood what you meant. I just don’t agree that coming to this conclusion makes somebody a fool given the context.
Fair enough
Because it means they don’t know anything but have an opinion anyways.
Because they’re the same sort person who thinks a titmouse is a sexy rodent?
Thats really getting into pedantics, but theres nothing saying that it cant be a symbotic relationship.
There’s a tension between socialism and internationalism. If you’re going to tax the wealthy to give money to the poor, you run the risk of the wealthy leaving the country and more poor people arriving. There’s also the issue of many voters not being super solidaric with those who are not like them. In a sense, all socialism ends up being national by necessity. I don’t think that’s the worst thing ever. The policy combination of welfare and tight borders (or at least a citizenship that’s hard to get) does not inevitably lead to concentration camps.
There’s no tension. They can leave but they can’t take everything with them. And even what they can take they can only do it for so long before they run out of places to run to.
One big reason you need self-sufficency within individual socialist districts. Taxation is just a tool to rebalance the scales. But at the end of the day, socialists need sovereignty - control over their natural resources and freedom from outside economic extortion.
That doesn’t preclude internationalism. But it does preclude imperialism.
Other way around. All socialism must be globalist or you’re simply exporting the exploitation. The fleeing of the oligarchy is irrelevant to actual socialism, as their stolen wealth should have been seized, and is only a problem for liberal welfare state models like social democracy.
deleted by creator
In both systems the normal people serve the ones who have all the guns
Okay buddy ancap
I did Nazi that coming
Got’em
Is that germane to your interests?
I hate Nazis, they’re coarse and rough and irritating… and they get everywhere.
Not on lemmy, here we only have to deal with tankies.
a rose by any other name …
I hate Tatooine Nazis.
Did you ever hear the story of Karl Marx the wise?
I have a fake white supremacist Facebook account so I can troll Nazis. I’m gonna show them this and see if they get it.
Keep me updated
With the Madison and Monroe Doctrines the United States treats its neighbors like colonies except Canada with burned the mutherfucking White House down … and Congress.
And national socialism is at it core the idea that one doesn’t need to go halfway around the world to treat a population like they are a colony of savages.
So minus the public health care and free university education the US is already there.
At least it’s an ethos…
It’s 100% pathos
